Is It Cheaper To Build Out Or Up?

is it cheaper to build out or up? home builder melbourne
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    When a homeowner is thinking about adding on to their home, one of the most often questions they ask me is whether it is preferable to "up up" with an addition that is on the second level or to "go out" with an addition that is on the ground floor.

    Whether or not there is opportunity for expansion on the same level is, of course, the first consideration that should be considered. In your neighbourhood, what are the required distances between buildings called for? Are you prepared to relinquish some of the area in your yard? In most cases, the simplest and most cost-effective solution is to construct an extension on the ground level if there is enough room to do so. If, on the other hand, you are limited by setbacks or don't want to give up the yard space, a second story addition can be a better choice for you.

    Homeowners frequently ask, given the potential for savings on foundation expenses, whether it is more cost-effective to build "up" rather than out. To put it simply, yes and no. It depends on how much weight the foundation is capable of supporting. If you want to build on top of the existing house, you might need to have the foundation repaired or add support posts to the walls. Because a garage is often constructed on a slab and may support a second story, doing some of this labour and spending some of this money on it can be avoided by building on top of the garage.

    The location of the steps is an additional factor to take into consideration. When the addition is constructed on top of the garage, room for the stairs can be obtained from within the garage itself. This reduces the amount of disruption to the floor plan of the current property. See our list of available builder services melbourne to help you make an informed decision for your treatment.

    In general, second-story additions have a tendency to have a greater impact on the existing home than ground-floor additions do, which results in an increase in the scope of the project as well as the associated expense. If you intend to build "up," you should strive to construct as much of the addition as you can above the existing garage. However, if there is enough room, going "out" is most likely the easiest method for you to implement.

    Because every condition is different, working with a design-build firm can assist you in determining what options would be most suitable for your specific needs.

    If you want to increase the amount of living space in your home, there is no foolproof way to evaluate whether adding a second story or an addition will be the least expensive option to do it without first evaluating the specifics of the property. When compared to the cost of constructing a second story, an addition may be a more cost-effective option for certain homeowners; however, this is not always the case.

    Space You Need

    If you have a growing family but not enough bedrooms or bathrooms, expanding either vertically or horizontally can be a viable solution. If, on the other hand, your major demands concern additional leisure room, such as a den or playroom, then it may make more sense to build an extension as opposed to adding a second storey to your home. This is due to the fact that you should be concerned with the resale value of your property, and the vast majority of people prefer to have a family-type room on the ground floor rather than one located upstairs. The second story of a home is often reserved for sleeping quarters and is not a location where visitors are welcome for social gatherings. It makes no sense to instal the kitchen on the second floor if you want it to be larger because of the limited space.

    is it cheaper to build out or up? melbourne

    Consider Your Property

    Your choice will be heavily influenced by the dimensions and configuration of your land. If you have a sizable backyard, an addition to your home won't have as significant of an effect as it would if you had a back yard that was on the more compact side. In certain instances, you won't have a choice since the size of the addition you want to put in your backyard just won't fit into the space available to you. Take into consideration the possibility that you may, at some point in the future, desire to add a swimming pool or make other alterations to your home. A lot of property owners understand that they can get a buildout addition or a pool, but not both at the same time. If you like your yard, building higher makes more sense.

    Consider Zoning Issues

    Get in touch with your local government to find out what the zoning regulations are in your neighbourhood before you make a choice. Setback regulations are probably something that your municipality has passed laws on, and they dictate how near you can construct to the property line of your neighbour. A town may also have ordinances governing the maximum height of a residence that may be constructed, however there aren't many towns that outright ban the construction of a second story. It's possible that you won't have the option to build upward on your property if it's located in a historic district or a community that was designed around single-story houses. If, on the other hand, you are dead-set on constructing an addition despite the fact that your plans do not comply with the setback requirements, you may be able to present your case to a zoning board of adjustment in the hope that it will allow you to construct the addition anyway and grant you a variance from the setback requirements. Given that your near neighbours are aware of your plans, it may be in your best interest to have a conversation with them in advance to see whether or not they will object to what you have in mind.

    If you build upward rather than outward, you can increase the square footage of the structure without raising the expenditures for the building's foundation or the additional roofing materials. This means that you effectively multiply the amount of area available for occupation by two (or whichever many levels you desire). Building upwards will save you money on the cost of the lot because it will allow you to purchase a smaller one (especially when expanding lots out may not be readily available). When compared to building out, which frequently involves expanding low-cost commercial or not-for-sale property, building up in a small lot size allows for the creation of a significantly larger amount of usable vertical space.

    There are additional benefits that come along with constructing upwards rather than outwards. By building upward, builders have the ability to more easily alter entire levels, if that is what the customer desires. That is to say, with a smaller amount of space, more businesses are able to afford a complete floor that can be customised to their preferences without having to worry about having to share space with another business. Naturally, it is possible to personalise any working environment. On the other hand, it's possible that less substantial businesses would benefit more from not sharing a floor. In a built-out environment, having multiple offices or stores located next to one another can be noisier for the tenants of the building than having the offices separated by floors. Single-story buildings may have smaller exteriors, but multi-story structures may have more spectacular sizes, and owners of multi-story buildings can charge additional rent for signs (such as on the top of a multi-story office building).

    There are, however, some advantages to building out rather than up. 

    For instance, there are certain advantages to having a location that is closer to the parking lot, and this is especially true for establishments that cater to consumers who have impairments. In addition, compared to multi-story buildings, single-story structures offer greater opportunities for unique architectural flourishes, such as skylights and vaulted ceilings designed specifically for the space. Considering a new project? Then MJS Construction Group builders Melbourne is the answer.

    In most cases, expanding upwards will result in lower overall construction costs. Expanded elevator shafts and more intricate HVAC systems are examples of things that can make vertical construction more expensive than horizontal construction in specific circumstances. As a result of these and other considerations, buildings with more than twenty stories can have an effect on the prices, in contrast to structures with fewer than twenty stories.

    Building Out

    The bulk of extensions entail expanding the footprint of the level that is located on the ground floor of the structure. This is partly due to the fact that the majority of additions are made to the first floor of a home, whether the homeowner is enlarging the kitchen, adding a family room, or resides in a home with only one level.

    What's Involved: Your general contractor will, in most cases, bring in a piece of excavating equipment known as a backhoe to dig up the yard in the area where the addition will sit, instal a new foundation or slab, then construct the walls and roof of the addition before opening up the existing exterior wall and linking the new and old spaces.

    Advantages: Because you are not supporting the new space over the existing structural framing or foundation, building out typically causes the least amount of disruption to the existing space — and to your life, if you are living at home during the project. This is because you are not building the new space on top of the existing space. In addition, if you are only planning to construct a modest addition, you might be able to get away without doing any foundation work at all by doing a bump out instead.

    Disadvantages: Building out involves giving up some of your yard space, and it may even require a zoning variance from the municipality if you live inside the legal property line "setback," which is normally 7.5 feet from the property line of the neighbouring property. You can also run into restrictions imposed by the town's Floor-Area-Ratio rating. This rating determines what percentage of a lot can be built on, and it takes into account things like the house, the garage, and the driveway.

    Building Up

    There are a number of different methods that additions can be made to a house without increasing its overall footprint: You have the ability to construct an additional level onto a home that already has one or even two stories. The addition of huge dormers into a pitched roof allows for the creation of additional usable living space that can be added to an existing upper level. You may even construct a living space on top of an existing garage, porch, sunroom, or wing of the house that is only one storey tall.

    What's Involved:Your contractor will probably need to expose the existing foundation and wall structure under the new space in order to ensure that it can support the additional weight. This is necessary even though there is no requirement for the addition to have a new foundation, so there is no need to give up a portion of the yard for the foundation. The addition of a new room places a large additional stress on all of the components that are located underneath it.

    Pros: You won't lose any yard space, and you won't run into any zoning restrictions related to minimum setbacks or maximum floor area ratios.

    Cons: There are a lot of municipalities that put height restrictions on homes, which might be a problem if you want to expand upward. If you are adding an entire new level to your home, you will also need to make room for a stairwell, which may easily consume anywhere from 80 to 120 square feet or even more of the available living area. And your contractor will probably have to knock away the walls and ceilings in the space below in order to strengthen the structural supports and feed in the electrical, plumbing, and heating lines. This is something that needs to be done in order to complete the project.

    is it cheaper to build out or up?

    Up vs. Out

    There are numerous exceptions to the rule that says it is cheaper to develop upwards rather than outwards; nonetheless, in general, this is true. HomeAdvisor estimates that the average cost of building additions falls anywhere between $80 and $200 per square foot, regardless of whether the addition is vertical or horizontal. Even while building upwards is typically less expensive than building outwards, this only accounts for the cost of the actual construction. Because the contractor must remove the roof before adding additional story to your home, it is highly likely that you will be required to find alternative housing while the work is finished. If you do not have friends or family who are willing to house you and your family for a while, you will need to either rent another home or stay in a hotel during this time period, and the costs associated with either option are significant. You will have to deal with the dust and interruption caused by construction if you are building out, but otherwise you will be able to remain in the same location.

    The costs can also change depending on the specific tasks that need to be completed by the contractor. Because the builder must do excavation work and establish a new foundation, the cost of an addition is typically more than the cost of the original structure. When the construction of your home is getting close to being finished, the contractor will need to open up the external wall so that the old and new may be linked together. If you do decide to expand upwards, you will need to ensure that the foundation you already have is solid enough to hold the weight of an additional story. In the event that the foundation needs to be retrofitted, one of the charges will be the demolition of your current walls, which would drive up your overall expenses significantly. Be aware that adding another storey requires the construction of a staircase, which will necessitate the relocation of valuable square footage on the ground level.

    The Sun Room Factor

    A comfortable playroom or family room can be created in a sunroom, which is one of the most cost-effective modifications that can be made to a home. According to HomeAdvisor, the typical price of a prefabricated sunroom is approximately $16,315. If you live in a region with mild winters, you won't need to bother about heating the sunroom at all. On the other hand, if you reside in a region with colder winters, you'll be able to save money by not heating this space and only making use of it for three of the year's four seasons.

    Consider Attic Conversions

    If your home includes an attic, you might be able to get the additional space you need at a lower cost by converting it into a bedroom and bathroom or a family room rather than expanding the footprint of the house or constructing an actual second storey. If your roof is old or leaking, you may be required to replace it; however, this typically entails simply installing a new roof atop the existing one, which is a task that a contractor can typically complete in a matter of a couple of days. For an attic conversion, you may anticipate spending between $50,000 and $65,000 total. You will not be required to evacuate the building while work is being done, in contrast to a conversion of the second storey.

    Consider Cost Breakdowns

    Discussing the calculations with your builder or architect is the only way to determine which of expanding upwards or outwards will result in a lower overall cost. You should figure that the latter will cost between 10 and 17 percent of the total budget, but it is essential to work with an architect in the majority of cases to ensure that the addition looks good with the house. If your addition will only consist of one room and will only have one door leading into the main house, however, you may be able to get away with hiring a general contractor rather than an architect. A build-up requires the services of an architect. If you decide to go that route, make sure you ask to see examples of similar work that the contractor has completed. You do not want to wind up with an addition that appears to be slapped on to the rest of the house and that is not desirable from an aesthetic standpoint.

    Examine the prices of the preliminary work. According to HomeAdvisor, the average cost of excavation is $2,559; however, if the size of your addition is higher than usual, you will wind up spending more. The cost of using concrete for the footings comes to about $75 per cubic yard, while the cost of support beams and roof trusses is between $15 and $30 per square foot. Then there are the specific considerations that need to be made, such as the kind of flooring that should be installed. Vinyl flooring is the least cheapest option, but it is not nearly as appealing as more expensive options like genuine stone, ceramic tile, or wood.

    Increasing Your Home Value

    When calculating the expenses associated with an addition, you need also think about how much it will increase the value of your home. When you build an addition onto your home, you almost never get a return on your investment that is equal to or more than the amount of money you put into it. This means that if you invest $75,000, the value of your property may not necessarily increase by the same amount. However, the return on investment for certain enhancements is significantly higher than that of others. If you add a master suite to your home, you may recoup as much as 63% of your initial investment when you go to sell it. The addition of a new bathroom can raise the value of a home by approximately 53%, while a sunroom can raise it by just under 50%.

    Building Up or Out: What Each Involves

    When it comes to increasing the amount of space in your home, one option is to increase the footprint of the bottom floor. To a property that already has two stories, you have the option of including a complete or half second storey as well as either a full or partial third floor. Nevertheless, it is essential to have a solid understanding of the processes involved in carrying out vertical and horizontal increases.

    Vertical Additions

    When you make vertical expansions, you are constructing upward rather than outward. This indicates that the present roof on your property will either be completely or partially removed. Once the roof has been removed, you may want to think about staying in a hotel or with family members for the remainder of the renovation because you won't be able to heat or cool the home and may not be able to use services like the water supply, which may need to be turned off during the renovation process. If you don't plan ahead, you may not be able to use these amenities. If you're looking for a high-quality, affordable builder in Melbourne, you're in the right place! Check MJS Construction Group!

    If your house now only has one level, extending it vertically will require the construction of an additional staircase. This will necessitate taking up space on the first floor, which will result in a reduction in the total amount of space that can be utilised. You may instal a staircase close to the front door of your first-floor home if there is sufficient room in front of the door on the first level. If the area of your home that serves as the entryway is already busy, you may work with architects and designers to locate a place in the house that is more convenient to put in the new staircase.

    Horizontal Additions

    When you horizontally expand your home, you reduce the amount of space that is accessible in your yard. On the other hand, if you don't use your backyard very frequently, this can be a good alternative for you because it will require less maintenance on the grass and the landscaping around it. Not to mention, horizontal additions aren't as disruptive as second- and third-floor additions because they often occur outside of the home's major rooms. This is another reason why horizontal additions are more popular.

    Pouring a foundation is the first step in the construction of a horizontal extension. After that, the walls are framed, any necessary plumbing and air ducts are installed, and a roof is constructed over the newly added portion of the structure. The horizontal additions must be positioned and designed so that they flow with your existing floor plan, and the exterior siding or brick, as well as the roof, must be built so that it matches the existing exterior. Additionally, horizontal additions must be designed so that they flow with your existing ceiling plan. If the new ground-level addition is not matched to the existing home, there may be a visual and practical disconnect between the older and newer parts of the house.

    Whether you choose to construct horizontally or vertically will be determined by the size of your property, the zoning regulations and HOA restrictions in your neighbourhood, the condition of your existing home, the precise requirements you have, as well as your available funds.

    Frequently Asked Questions About Building A House

    A home with a simple and concise layout is the cheapest type of house to build. Ranch homes are typically single-story structures with attached garages.

    Building a family home can take around seven months. A custom home generally takes more time to build, depending on how elaborate the plans are.

    Building up is always the least expensive option for increasing your home's square footage because it requires less material and labour. For example, if you have 1,000 sq. feet on the main level and want 1,000 sq. feet on a second floor, you must add more wood and framing labour.

    According to the Urban Development Institute of Australia's (UDIA) 2021 State of the Land report, Sydney's median lot price in 2020 was $495,000, or approximately $1,285 per sqm. The cost of building in NSW can then vary between $1,780 per sqm for an average low-cost build and up to $5,100 for a typical premium build.

    All costs include stamp duty. The cost of building includes land purchase, and assumes a first home owner concession on stamp duty where applicable. According to our figures, Perth is the only major Australian city where buying could be cheaper than building.

    Google Rating
    Based on 24 reviews
    Scroll to Top