Is It Cheaper To Add On Or Build Up?

how do i find a reputable home builder? home builder melbourne
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    If you find that you require additional space in your home, you may be debating whether or not it would be more prudent to construct an addition or to build upward. Your choice will be influenced by a number of factors and limitations, each of which must be taken into consideration. Not only those in relation to the finances, but also those in relation to the amount of land you have and whether or not your city will permit you to build out.

    Analysing the specific space requirements for this project is another another approach that may be taken with it. Building additional space on the second floor is not an option if your objective is, for instance, to enlarge your kitchen, which is often situated on the ground floor of a home or other building. Let's have a look at some things to think about, shall we?

    Which way is it? The question is exactly this. You want the greatest space possible for the least amount of money, but you also value efficiency. It is possible that the location of your future home will determine your choice. It's possible that the only option you have is to build upward, especially if your home doesn't have much of a yard to the sides or behind it. In addition, there is the factor of the local zoning restrictions. Because every circumstance is unique, determining which option is the most cost-effective is subject to a number of variables.

    How much additional square footage does it cost to build onto a house? That is dependent on a wide range of circumstances, including location as well as whether or not you are building upwards or horizontally. This post will discuss the several affordable options, as well as the benefits and drawbacks associated with each one.

    It is difficult to ignore the state of continual building that exists in many real estate markets today. It looks like everyone wants to pile stuff higher and higher all around them. This is especially relevant for homeowners who wish to increase the value of their house as well as add some additional space to it. The issue is, constructing an extension to a house and constructing additional rooms is not exactly an inexpensive endeavour. Are you thinking about giving your home a makeover? No need to look any further! The MJS Construction Group is available to assist you in all of your home building needs.

    People frequently implement some form of strategy into their building in the hope that it will make life easier. Because of this, people have a tendency to consider the cost of building upwards as opposed to building outwards. The issue is that it is not always simple to determine which option will result in a lower cost. So, what exactly is going on here?

    What Is Involved In Building An Addition?

    Your builder will have to submit a plan to the city in order to obtain the proper permissions, if any are required, before beginning construction on an addition, which will result in an increase in the footprint of your home. After that, digging machinery will be brought in to prepare the ground for the additional foundation that will be placed there. Your current outside wall won't be knocked down and both spaces won't be connected until after the construction of the new space has been completed, at which point it will have walls and a roof.

    Are There Advantages Or Disadvantages To Building An Addition?

    One of the many benefits of undergoing this construction in your house is that you may continue to live there while it is being done. In the event of modest additions, it's possible that foundation work won't be required.

    The possibility exists that you will wind up with a smaller backyard, and there is also the possibility that you will run into issues with your municipal government if a zoning exception is required. The setback from the property line has been violated by your addition. There is a possibility that the city in which you live will place restrictions on the ratio of floor space to total area.

    What Is Involved In Building Up?

    Increasing the height of your home provides you with a number of opportunities to acquire the much-required additional living space. You might go all out and plan to add a second storey to a house that already has one, or you could plan to add a third floor to a house that already has two stories. If you currently have a pitched roof, another option would be to dormer out a portion of the floor space that you already have. Alternately, you may transform your attic, sunroom, or porch into a habitable space.

    Are There Advantages Or Disadvantages To Building An Addition?

    Aside from the fact that you won't have to give up even a single square inch of your backyard, the most significant benefit is that you won't have to worry about running afoul of any zoning restrictions that pertain to setbacks or floor-area-ratio limitations. These kinds of limitations can cause problems.

    is it cheaper to build out or up?

    One of the potential drawbacks is the fact that the height of a home may be restricted in many municipalities due to predetermined height restrictions. In addition, adding a second or third story will reduce the amount of floor space you have available once a staircase is installed. There is a possibility that you will run into problems with the additional structural supports that are need to hold the weight of the new area.

    When it comes to increasing the amount of living space in your home, there are so many factors and constraints that will end up influencing your decision. For this reason, you need rely on the assistance of a construction professional to assist you in determining what works and is practical and what does not function and is not feasible.

    Why Should You Expand Your Home?

    If you ask any homeowner who is in the process of adding onto their home why they want the addition, you can be sure that they will each offer you a different reason for desiring the expansion. There is no single, universal justification that may be used for expanding a home. The following are some of the most common explanations why:

    • Expanding the family- Many home addition projects get their start from having another child or deciding to make the switch to a multigenerational home. 
    • Increasing property value- Bigger homes are generally seen as being more desirable and can command a bigger price tag.
    • Getting a home office- If you work out of your home, you might want to get a room that's entirely dedicated to it. This is one of the few ways to make an expansion into a tax advantage for you.
    • As a treat- Sometimes, people want to expand their homes because they've always wanted a dedicated room for themselves. Who wouldn't want their hobby room?
    • Keeping up with the neighbourhood- Let's face it. No one wants to be the tiniest house on the block. If everyone else is expanding, it's safe to say you might feel the pressure to do so, too. 

    Is It Cheaper to Build Up or Out?

    This is a challenging subject that frequently has a lot to do with the cost of real estate and labour in the location in which you live. In the majority of locations, expanding outward rather than trying to expand upward is the more cost-effective option. This is due to the fact that constructing uphill takes a greater amount of labour, a greater quantity of materials, a number of permits, and the assistance of a structural engineer.

    Building upwards requires additional labour and materials, thus the only time you can fairly assume that it will be less expensive is when you are working with extremely expensive land. This is the only situation in which you may make this assumption. Even so, you can still find yourself asking other people, "Is it less expensive to build a second story or build out?"

    Get land to build on if you can, if you have the means to do so. There are just a few places in the world where purchasing land might present a considerable challenge, and the majority of these places are cities. If you live in Brooklyn or Manhattan and own a house, you could find that expanding your home vertically is in your best interest.

    Why Is Building Up So Expensive?

    Stability and safety are of the utmost importance. To put it another way, it takes a lot more effort to ensure that a home stays stable with several thousand pounds added on than it does to add another room when the property is already standing on firm ground. While there is no cause for concern when it comes to constructing out rather than up, some houses do not have the structural integrity necessary to support an upward extension without extra support. Looking for accommodations with room for two? No need to look any further! You are in good hands with MJS Construction Group.

    Extra Labor

    Because building upward involves adding one or more rooms to the first floor of your home, there is a significant probability that you will need to add structural support to your home in order to keep it stable after the addition of these rooms. You are going to need to hire a structural engineer to examine your house in order to determine whether or not you will have to carry out any further maintenance or repairs.

    In addition, it is essential to be aware that building upward also necessitates the demolition of the existing home's roof as well as other components of the structure. Your prices for labour will increase due to the increased complexity of this relocation, which may necessitate the demolition of a wall and the removal of siding.

    Extra Materials

    No matter what you intend to do with the additional space, there are going to be a few things that you need to purchase that wouldn't be required in the case of an outward extension. For instance, a standard first-floor extension does not necessitate the installation of stairs, additional support beams, or components that require bolstering the robustness of your flooring in any way.

    You are going to require those things when you have an upward expansion of your business. When you make consistent additions to the outside of your home, the only things you need to be concerned about are the fundamentals, such as the electrical wiring and plumbing. Because of this, expanding outward is typically an endeavour that can be completed at a cheaper cost.

    Permit costs

    Permits are something that no one wants to worry about, but in order to successfully complete a remodelling project, you really need to take them into consideration. The majority of cities will require additional permits and inspections to ensure that everything is safe before allowing you to build upwards due to the inherent danger that comes with doing so. In addition, this will result in an increase in the total cost.

    How Much Easier Is It To Expand Outward?

    The majority of people believe that expanding outwards is a more simpler sort of remodelling to work with, provided there are no severe regulatory obstacles or a lack of available land. This is why:

    • Less money needs to be spent- This is the biggest thorn in most peoples' sides, by far. You will need to spend more on labour, stairs, and other materials if you want to build up. If you can get a better deal expanding outward than upward, why wouldn't you take it? 
    • Planning is more straightforward- If you dislike having to jump through hoops to get stuff going, then building out is almost always the better choice. Even planning how you're going to be able to add additional structural boosters can take a while!
    • Fewer repairs need to be made- When you build up, you often have to repair the wear and tear that occurred on your existing structure before anything else can be done. This usually eats up both time and money.
    • Expanding upwards usually takes longer- Because of all the added work (structuring, roof removal, etc.), opting for an upwards expansion can take several months longer than an outward expansion. 
    • Attaining permits is usually easier, too- Townships are well aware of the issues that come with building up instead of building out. As a result, permits are often harder to attain, with some areas going so far as to ban building up entirely. 
    • Most people have enough land to add an extra room or two- It also comes down to availability. In most cases, people have enough space to build out. This means a lot less hassle. 

    How To Choose Your Expansion Style? 

    The advantages of expanding outward are quite substantial, yet expanding outward is not the right choice for everyone. There are circumstances in which constructing an addition can be the superior choice, even if doing so would incur additional costs. Extending upwards is a preferable option than building outwards, for instance, if you don't have the land or if building out will make your home an eyesore.

    There will be times when expanding outwards is not a viable option. Building upwards could be the only way to gain the additional space you need if, for instance, the use of additional land for home extensions is prohibited by a law in your municipality.

    "Up or out?"

    Homeowners who are looking for an answer to this age-old topic frequently approach the home addition contractors that we work with here at our company. Which is better: building horizontally or vertically when you're adding on to your house? In other words, should you add a second story to your home or construct an addition on the ground floor?

    Free additions consultation.

    There is no straightforward solution to this question, much like there isn't one for many other aspects of home remodelling. Whether expanding outward or upward is the better strategy for your situation depends on a number of different aspects, including the following:

    The size and shape of your property. 

    If you do not have enough room to build vertically or horizontally, or if you do not wish to give up any of your yard area, the best option for you is to build upward. By constructing above, you'll be able to free up space below for other endeavours, such as swimming pools, gardens, and storage sheds.

    The type of addition. 

    It is recommended that some areas, such as the kitchen and the living room, be located on the ground floor. You should think about whether it would be more convenient to have your extension on the ground level or up a flight of stairs when making the decision between expanding upwards or expanding outwards.

    Zoning laws. 

    Your county may have certain regulations that restrict how close you are allowed to construct to your neighbours or the property boundary. These requirements can vary depending on where you live. However, there is a possibility that the municipal rules will impose restrictions on the height to which you are permitted to construct. The majority of local governments in the Mid-Atlantic region impose a maximum height restriction of 35 feet on residential buildings.

    is it cheaper to build out or up? melbourne


    It can be difficult to determine with absolute certainty which of the two strategies—growing up or building out—will result in the greater expense. The cost of building outward is typically higher than building in since it necessitates excavation work in addition to the construction of an additional foundation and basement. Nevertheless, depending on the specifics of the situation, building upward may end up being the more expensive option because it may call for additional work on the structural support system in addition to the foundational work.


    Be aware that if you choose to build upward, you will almost probably be required to evacuate your house for a period of up to six months during the construction. This is due to the fact that your roof will need to be taken off in order for your builders to be able to construct the second level. When deciding whether or not building upward is the best option for you, you should think about how much it will cost you to find temporary living accommodations and to eat out.

    A Look at the Two Different Processes

    Are you still unsure what to do? Let's take a look at the overall process involved in each method of construction so that you can make an informed decision about whether or not to construct horizontally or vertically.

    Building out. 

    The decision to build out gives you and your contractor the opportunity to collaborate on the design of a home addition that meets your requirements and satisfies your preferences. When you have a plan that you are satisfied with, your contractor is required to submit it for approval by the relevant permitting agency.

    After the drawings have been reviewed and approved, your contractor will normally begin the project by excavating the yard in the area of the property where the new addition will be located and erecting a new foundation. After that, your contractor will probably start working on the new walls and the roof of the structure. At last, your contractor will cut a hole in the previously existing external wall in order to attach the new construction to the older one.

    Building up. 

    When constructing up, just as when building out, you and your contractor will need to submit design plans to the appropriate authorities for approval. After you have obtained your permission, the roof will need to be removed prior to the building of the second story being allowed to commence. They may also be required to make modifications to the building all the way down to the foundation in order to verify that it is capable of supporting an additional story. This may involve removing siding and disrupting the structure of the existing walls.

    If you are thinking of adding on to your home, it is in your best interest to discuss the project with your builder to determine the approach that will yield the best results given the specifics of your land and your life. Your contractor will be able to assist you with the design and construction of an addition to your house that increases the living space, the aesthetic appeal, and the value of your property, regardless of whether you choose to build up or out.

    Ground Floor Extensions

    is it cheaper to build a home yourself melbourne

    In the vast majority of cases, you should be able to stay in your house while the new extensions are being added, provided that you do not plan to remodel your kitchen or the old bathroom at the same time as adding on the extra rooms. This is because remodelling both of these spaces at the same time would require a significant amount of time.

    Even if you aren't required to move out of your home while your ground-level addition is being built, that doesn't mean that there won't be times when it's dusty and noisy. Because it is a construction site, it will be subject to the same kinds of conditions that you would expect to see while building a brand-new house.

    The good news is that the task will, in the vast majority of instances, take place during the typical workweek and during daylight hours (unless you and you builder make some special arrangements for work to be carried out outside normal "tradie hours"). Therefore, unless you are a shift worker, have a child in preschool who naps throughout the day, or work from home, it is doubtful that the noise will have a significant influence on you. Your dream home can become a reality when you work with MJS Construction Group, since we provide the finest selection of dual occupancy options.

    First-floor Additions

    Even if the concerns made concerning noise and dust equally apply to first-floor expansions in general, the good news is that in many situations, their impact in terms of time can be much less than what was originally anticipated. This is due to the fact that work will be done on top of your house (rather than at ground level).

    The floor of the new addition is installed once the roof of your house has been taken down in the region where the second story is going to be constructed. The wall frames and the roof structure for the second level are going to be constructed on top of the new floor. Next come the windows, the sheathing for the exterior walls, and the roof tiles.

    All of this work will be done outside of your current residence, and the builder's craftsmen will access the new second level using ladders and scaffolding. This is referred to as getting your new addition to the "lock-up" stage, in which it is protected from the elements by being enclosed. Because the new addition can only be accessed from the outside for the time being, the amount of dust and noise that enters your house should be kept to a minimum during this time.

    The work on the inside then gets on after lockup. Even yet, in many instances, the amount of noise and dust may not be too problematic until the later phases, when an aperture is formed in the ceiling of the downstairs area to accommodate the new staircase. This is because the new staircase requires more space. When that time arrives, having some patience while dealing with the noise and dust is going to be necessary.

    Is it more cost effective to expand upwards or outwards? Building your house outwards, rather than inwards, is going to be the less expensive choice for the vast majority of us, therefore that's our response. Despite the fact that it is the more affordable option, this does not necessarily guarantee that it will be the most beneficial answer for you.

    Building upwards or outwards is a very personal choice that needs to be carefully considered, just as does the decision to make any other significant change during the remodelling process. Consequently, the price is a consideration; nevertheless, it is also necessary to take into account the local legislation, the availability of land, and permissions.

    FAQs About Cheaper To Add On Or Build Up

    Ranch Homes

    A home with a simple and concise layout is the cheapest type of house to build. Ranch homes are typically single-story structures with attached garages. They're easy to find construction plans for and highly customizable, so you can find a home that fits your needs and budget.

    8 Inexpensive Building Materials That Don't Look Cheap

    • Build for Less. 1/9. 
    • Concrete Sheets. 2/9. 
    • Reclaimed Wood. 3/9.
    • Used Brick. 4/9. 
    • Corrugated Metal. 5/9. 
    • Stone Veneer. 6/9. 
    • Shipping Containers. 7/9. 
    • Bamboo. 8/9.

    Many people find that the straightforward design of an A-frame structure is attractive for either their primary residence or their vacation house. There is a possibility that the A-frame will be the most cost-effective solution; however, this will be contingent on the numerous decisions you make along the way regarding the materials, labour, and finishes.

    It's possible to save a lot of money by building your own house rather than buying one already on the market. It is possible to save as much as forty percent of the total cost if you carry out the work on your own. However, even saving money by employing builders to carry out the majority of the work and overseeing the construction project yourself can result in significant savings.

    Tata Group, which is best known for producing the world's cheapest automobile (which can be purchased for a price of $2,500), is applying its expertise in the field of home-building with the launch of its new Nano House.

    Google Rating
    Based on 24 reviews
    Scroll to Top